The Alfa Romeo Giulia Is The Perfect Unreliable Italian Car We've Always Dreamed Of
Michael Ballaban
BONG BONG BONG. The dashboard had lit up like a Christmas tree. Power was gone. The whole car started shuddering. We were in a 2017 Alfa Romeo Giuliawith just barely 1,709 miles on the odometer, and it was already breaking down.
Have you ever wanted the authentic Alfa Romeo experience? Because we were getting it now.
It’s not like we were doing anything crazy with it, either. If we had just driven it straight into a yawning sinkhole or something, I would totally get it. But we had just left last night’s Are You Faster Than A Jalopnik Writer Event—it went great, by the way, and yes, you are all definitely faster than us—and had pulled onto the highway.
Heading down I-87, the cruise control was set at 64 miles per hour, and there were no other cars on the road in front of us. Everything should have been completely smooth sailing.
That’s when the breakdown started. The lights came on, the BONGS started BONGING, and the throttle was barely working. I’d give it a light brush, and the car would go into conniption fits, its gearbox bogging and its motor unable to provide acceleration.
We were crawling along at 40 mph in the slow lane, the car refusing to go any faster as a truck roared past us doing 70. It was hard to tell whether the car was in limp mode, or had just begun to refuse the very concept of life itself.
The plan was to pray to our various gods, deities, and empty nothingness, and pull off at the next offramp while the car was still moving. An awkward moment ensued when there was actually a toll booth before the exit, and we didn’t know if the thing would move after coming to a halt.
But it did, crankily, and we pulled into a parking lot. We thought about calling the company that manages Alfa’s fleet, but we realized it was about 11 p.m. already, the car was full of five people, we were far from the nearest train station, and if we didn’t try to get it moving then, it might be a while before we ever made it home.
So we tried what everyone with computers does, and turned it off and on again. That seemed to cure whatever the hell was going on with the car’s jerky tantrum, for the moment.
We thankfully made it back to home base, dashboard lights still ablaze, but with the car (maybe?) in one piece.
I’d love to come out here right now and say “man, sometimes these press cars are thrashed, and they can get weird!” I’d love to say that absolutely nothing could go wrong with developing an entire car in only two-and-a-half years.I’d love to say this was an isolated, one-off incident, but it isn’t.
The fact is, Alfa Romeo’s comeback car has been plagued with problems, and these are increasingly well-documented by the journalists who have been testing them.
Consumer Reports’ Alfa has been to the dealer service bay three times since they bought it. The UK’s Sunday Times had three Giulias crap out on them. Forums abound with reliability issues. Pistonheads had an Alfa Giulia break down in the middle of a test against a Mercedes and a BMW. Motor Trend’s Alfa was completely defeated by a normal driveway. Car and Driver said that their Giulia suffered “foibles.”
And perhaps most damning of all, Road & Track’s Sam Smith said sister mag Car and Driver actually has “an in-house code reader all but earmarked for Alfas, and every test Giulia they’ve seen has had problems.” And then Sam just this morning posted about a Giulia that had broken down on him:
Been looking forward to this moment for two years. Finally got to track a Giulia. And you know what? To hell with it. Three separate sessions and a bunch of cooling and waiting to try to get this thing to behave, and it always ended like this. Each time it popped a check-engine light and turned stability control back on. The car's spectacular on a back road. It looks amazing, and it pulls people off sidewalks at intersections. But on a relatively mild summer day, the car couldn't hold together long enough to give me one full lap. And the prep instructions from FCA said we were supposed to stop every three laps to let the diff cool, if we saw problems. Busso would be laughing his ass off. . Guys: I'm not alone, and among journalists and test Giulias, this is hardly an isolated incident. History and public perception mean you're already fighting an uphill battle in this country. My last Giulia press car idled so unevenly it rocked the cabin, and it didn't like pulling away from stoplights. Car and Driver has an in-house code reader all but earmarked for Alfas, and every test Giulia they've seen has had problems. This is how you walk back into a room? Even Alfettas didn't hate life this much. . I'm admittedly biased. I wanted so badly for it to be good. Always been one of the hopeful suckers. I was once a professional Alfa wrench. I was once somehow lucky enough to slide Nuvolari's Tipo B around a track. I've helped set up Alfa Trans-Am race cars. I've driven almost every postwar Alfa model sold in this country. All of which isn't worth a bucket of piss except to let me say that I know where you came from. I know how reliable those cars were and still are, how much they loved abuse. In 2017, this is embarrassing, disappointing, unnecessary, and stupid. You owe it to the badge, the people who love it, and the soul of the thing: Do better. #alfaromeo#alfagiulia @alfaromeousa @alfaromeoofficial#giuliaquadrifoglio #giulianova
We e-mailed Alfa, and notified them of what happened with our Giulia. They are taking it back to Michigan for diagnosis tomorrow.
But in the meantime, as our car shuffled along like a zombie, I remembered what it was like to always desperately want an Alfa Romeo. I had visions in my head of Europeans slinging cars with chromed intake runners in the engine saying silly Italian words. I remembered what it was like watching Top Gearsling three old Alfas through a series of challenges as they slowly fell apart like decomposing zombies losing limbs.
“Alfa builds a car to be as good as a car can be,” Clarkson said. “Briefly.”
The Giulia genuinely is a solid driver’s car, when it works. If there was any doubt that by returning to our shores Alfa had lost its way, or had forgotten its roots, those fears can all be tossed aside.
The Alfa Giulia really is as good as a car like this can be. Briefly. But if Alfa thinks that’s enough to steal sales from Lexus or BMW, it is very mistaken.
